An Instructional Design Model for the Online Studio

Graphic Design Foundations Project
Course work from Graphic Design Foundations

Instructional design models address different dimensions of learning experience design, from procedural processes to structural considerations. Using an asynchronous Graphic Design Foundations course taught at North Island College (2023–2024) as a case study, this post reverse-engineers the course’s design to explore how instructional design models, ADDIE (Molenda, 2003) and Gibbons’ design layers (2013), can work together for educators moving studio courses online.

About the course and studio-teaching

Graphic Design Foundations introduces students to the formal elements of design and their use in visual communication. It uses studio-based teaching, the signature pedagogy of design education, where students learn through making, experimentation, peer critique, reflection and iterative practice (Crowther, 2013). This case study focuses on the course’s asynchronous online delivery.

ADDIE and Gibbons’ Design Layers

ADDIE (Molenda, 2003) provides a systematic process for designing learning experiences through five phases, while Gibbons’ design layers (2013) offer a complementary architectural perspective. Rather than prescribing a methodology, the layers help designers identify, organize and prioritize instructional design concerns. 

In the table below, columns are the five ADDIE phases, showing when a design decision is made, and rows are Gibbons’ seven design layers, showing what kind of decision it is. Each cell gives an example of that decision. The examples are illustrative rather than exhaustive.

Insights

Reverse-engineering the design process helped clarify how instructional design models can inform practice. Gibbons’ design layers (2013) make the hidden design decisions involved in creating a learning experience explicit and intentional by breaking a complex design into a system of manageable discrete pieces. This encourages designers to question assumptions and consider alternatives rather than defaulting to familiar solutions. For example, an asynchronous discussion forum may seem like an obvious choice for peer critique, but a synchronous session might better support the social and teaching presences (Garrison et al., 2000).

Strategy is the connective layer that translates the pedagogical intentions of studio-based learning into an organized sequence of learning activities, and its implementation has implications across all other layers. For example, designing peer critique involves strategy (when and how critique happens), message (the guidance and feedback language), control (how students participate), representation (how work is displayed) and data management (how feedback is collected). While the ADDIE (Molenda, 2003)  process is often applied sequentially, the design layers (Gibbons, 2013) are interconnected and weave throughout every step of the design process. Their relative importance will vary depending on the learning goals, learners, context and available technologies of a course. For an asynchronous online studio course, the control and media-logic layers specifically require particular consideration.

Conclusion

Designing an online studio is not simply a matter of choosing the right tools or transferring existing activities into a digital environment. It requires translating the pedagogical intentions of studio learning into deliberate design decisions. ADDIE (Molenda, 2003) provides a process for developing the experience, while Gibbons’ design layers (2013) help make its different dimensions visible and ensure they are considered together. Frameworks such as UDL (Rose & Meyer, 2002) and Community of Inquiry (Garrison et al., 2000) can further inform decisions about inclusion and the quality of learning interactions. 

References

Crowther, P. (2013). Understanding the signature pedagogy of the design studio and the opportunities for its technological enhancement. Journal of Learning Design, 6(3). https://doi.org/10.5204/jld.v6i3.155

Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2000). Critical inquiry in a text-based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education. The Internet and Higher Education, 2(2–3), 87–105. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1096-7516(00)00016-6

Gibbons, A. S. (2013). An Architectural Approach to Instructional Design. https://www.routledge.com/An-Architectural-Approach-to-Instructional-Design/Gibbons/p/book/9780415807395

Molenda, M. (2003). In search of the elusive ADDIE model. Performance Improvement, 42(5), 34–36. https://doi.org/10.1002/pfi.4930420508

Rose, D.H., and Meyer, A. (2002). Teaching every student in the digital age: Universal Design for Learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. https://www.cast.org/resources/tips-articles/teaching-every-student-in-the-digital-age-universal-design-for-learning/

1 thought on “An Instructional Design Model for the Online Studio”

  1. Hi Claire,
    I really appreciated you pulling back the curtains to provide a window into the designing of your asynchronous graphic designs foundation course. I will be taking a graphic design for instructional designers course through RRU in 2027 and am quite curious about how that work will unfold. While some might question the potential of an online studio, the work of Sylvia Kind has informed my practice into thinking about the concept of “studio” as more of an idea rather than a physical place. One just needs to be “incited and provoked to engage in continuous experimentation” (Pacini-Ketchabaw, Kind, & Kocher, 2017). I also read a great children’s book that further added insight into this when I was opening a children’s art studio without access to a physical stand alone studio space that was entirely my own, and was hesitant to include the word “studio” in my business name. The book was called Studio: A Place for Art to Start by Emily Arrow and illustrated by The Little Friends of Printmaking and the idea was that a studio could look like a great many ways, but the important part is the creative acts that occur there.

    I think layering your methods to deliver this course demonstrates the great benefit of being a designer of instruction; you have the opportunity to design these spaces of learning without being restricted to just one model. I think you have created a really helpful graphic that tells the tale of your course through two effective models that work very well together. In my post, I explore the idea of “remixing” instructional design models.

    I would love to leave you with a question that I am still grappling with, being new to this course and the world of design. It came up as part of my research of the Dick & Carey System Approach Model from the Systematic Design of Instruction (2022). The authors distinguish, “The reader should be careful to distinguish between the process of designing instruction and the delivery of that instruction” (p. 12). I’m curious if based on your rich experiences, do you also see this as a valuable distinction to make?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top