Last week I said I didn’t have the vocabulary yet. This week I have some, and it turns out I’ve been using pieces of it for years. When I build something, I try it on real people before it’s final, the same way a finisher dry-fits before gluing. I just didn’t know that habit had a name.
For Assignment 1 I’m comparing three instructional design models: ADDIE, Backward Design and the Successive Approximation Model, usually shortened to SAM. I expected a list of steps for each. What I found, once I put them side by side, is that the difference that mattered most to me was when each one asks you to find out whether the learning worked.
In the way most teams run it, ADDIE puts evaluation last. Backward Design makes you write down the evidence you’d accept before you plan a single activity (Wiggins & McTighe, 2005). SAM has you build rough versions and put them in front of learners early and often (Allen & Sites, 2012). It’s the same worry in all three, with the instrument placed in a different spot.
That sent me back to the cockpit. When I practised instrument flying under the training hood, a visor that blocks everything outside the windows, I learned you don’t wait until you’ve landed to check the altimeter. You check it all the way down, because the thing you feel and the thing that’s true can be far apart. A learner who says “yes, that makes sense” is giving me the inner-ear reading. I want the altimeter.
Reading Molenda (2003) surprised me. He argues that ADDIE was never one carefully specified model, more an umbrella term for a family of approaches. I’d been treating it as a rigid procedure and blaming it for problems that probably come from how people run it. Our instructor, Lisa, also pointed out that Universal Design for Learning is a framework rather than a model, which I would have lumped in with the others a week ago. A framework gives me a lens on decisions I’m already making, and a model gives me steps. I can see a use for each.
Here’s where I’ve landed for now. When I’m choosing, I think the most useful question is how expensive it would be to find out I’m wrong. For a short course aimed at adults who were told school wasn’t for them, finding out late is expensive, so I’d want something close to SAM, with a rough version in front of real people early. For training where the content is fixed and the outcome is easy to name, the Backward Design question does most of the work: what would convince me this person can do the thing? And for a large project with stable content and a team that needs formal sign-off, ADDIE’s structure is probably doing exactly what it was meant to.
I haven’t tested any of this on a real project yet, so treat it as a first draft of a belief.
If you’re comparing models too, which one did you expect to prefer before you started, and did the comparison change your mind?
References
Allen, M. W., & Sites, R. (2012). Leaving ADDIE for SAM: An agile model for developing the best learning experiences. ASTD Press.
Molenda, M. (2003). In search of the elusive ADDIE model. Performance Improvement, 42(5), 34–36.
Wiggins, G., & McTighe, J. (2005). Understanding by design (Expanded 2nd ed.). Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Leave a Reply