
I could not attend our first Community Reflection, so I reviewed the session afterward. What struck me most was how one shared learning outcome, “identify strategies for responding respectfully to disagreements and achieving positive outcomes,” turned into completely different designs depending on who the learners were. I chose to reflect on first responders, partly because their group did not get a chance to share, and partly because it’s close to my own world. As an occupational health nurse with ITLS and Advanced First Aid training, I’ve been on the learner side of emergency education many times.
Who are the learners?
To make the audience concrete, I started with a quick persona: Jordan, a paramedic with eight years of experience, working rotating 12-hour shifts. Jordan is skilled, practical, and a little skeptical of anything that feels like “soft skills” training. Jordan faces disagreement in two very different places. On scene, it might be a frightened family member, a patient refusing care, or a tense handover with police or fire. Back at the station, it might be friction within crew after a hard call.
What shapes the design?
A few factors stood out:
- Stress and fatigue. Disagreements on scene happen when adrenaline is high. Strategies that work in a calm classroom may disappear under pressure.
- Time and scheduling. Shift work makes long sessions unrealistic, so short, repeatable learning fits better.
- Culture and credibility. First responders tend to value practical, peer-validated knowledge. Training that feels disconnected from real calls will lose them quickly.
- Emotional load. Cumulative stress and difficult calls affect how people respond to conflict. Psychological safety in the learning space would be essential, especially when debriefing real experiences.
- Standards. Like the customer service and nursing examples in the session, there are protocols and scope-of-practice limits that set non-negotiable boundaries around how responders can act.
Design decisions
I would start to Backward Design, which Dousay (2017) notes is one of the more well-known design models, including among educators outside corporate settings. If the outcome is identifying respectful strategies, the evidence I would want is learners recognizing escalation and choosing a strategy in a realistic scenario, not just listing techniques on a quiz. From there, the activities would follow: short case-based sessions, simulated scenes with actors or peers, and structured debriefs where responders analyze what worked.
I would layer UDL over that plan. That could mean offering scenarios as video, role-play, or written cases; a pocket-sized reference card with a simple memorable process (like the “stop, drop, and roll” idea from the youth coach group); and choice in how learners reflect, whether by talking it through in a debrief or writing privately (CAST, 2024).
Insights and questions
Matt’s group observed that for their audience, the learning activity was the outcome: participating respectfully in the session meant practicing the skill. I think that’s true here too. A well-run debrief models the very conversation skills we want responders to use.
The question I am left with connects to my own practice: there’s a big gap between identifying a strategy and using it under stress. How do we design assessment that captures real understanding, not just recall? As Mager put it, “If telling were teaching, we’d all be so smart we could hardly stand it” (Mager, 1968, as cited in Dousay, 2017) In safety and emergency training, that gap matters. It’s the same tension I see when a signature on a training record is treated as proof that learning happened.
This exercise reminded me that ID models aren’t step-by-step recipes. They are lenses, and the learner decides which ones bring the design into focus. It also brings me back to the question from my design identity post: what does this person need to be able to do when I am not there?
References
CAST. (2024). Universal Design for Learning guidelines version 3.0. https://udlguidelines.cast.org/
Dousay, T.A. (2017). Chapter 22. Instructional design models. In R. West (Ed.), Foundations of learning and instructional design technology (1st ed.). EdTech Books. https://edtechbooks.org/lidtfoundations/instructional_design_models
Leave a Reply