Skip to content

Category: Uncategorized

The Importance of Design in Teaching and Learning

By Vince R

The case of the boring classroom.

I am a certified teacher, a storyteller, and someone who has always been interested in creative things. As a kid, I would draw comics, write stories and play Dungeons and Dragons with my friends. Today, although I teach English and Social Studies in high school, I still enjoy a good story. Here is a little about how I arrived here. My journey into education didn’t begin in a classroom. Before becoming a teacher, I spent some time pursuing acting. I was attracted to the physical expression, the opportunity to be creative, and become immersed in a story. As you might know, acting is a relationship between the performer and the audience. You’re not simply presenting a story; you’re building it together with the experience of the audience. The audience brings its own imagination, emotions, and interpretation to what is happening. That’s why sometimes stories work best when some of the details are left unsaid and open to interpretation.

I eventually needed to move into a new career, and teaching felt like a natural progression. In acting, you’re building a story with an audience. In teaching, you’re building a learning experience with students. However, I noticed a difference that was occurring in the classroom for the most part, and that was that kids were not enjoying school. This seemed odd to me in a way because kids love learning. They learn constantly, often without even realizing it. They are excited to learn on the playground, making up game rules, experimenting, and discovering new things. They learn when watching television shows and love becoming immersed in stories and characters. They pick up new video games, spend hours learning complicated rules, develop new strategies, and persist through hard levels and challenges. They learn all this for fun because they want to, so why does that enthusiasm sometimes disappear when they walk into a classroom? I was in my teaching certification program and wanted to understand this mystery and learn how I could make learning in the classroom fun again. The answer to this, I found, was in examining the traditional education lesson format. What was the design for the classroom? Was the emphasis on listening rather than doing? Were students learning facts without engaging with them? How were the students’ emotions engaged? It became clear that sometimes education could become so focused on the intended outcome and could lose sight of the experience of getting there. This style of teaching, that I now call teacher default mode, emphasizes learning by lectures and power points that don’t engage or challenge students. When students are told what they need to know, what they need to do, and what they need to demonstrate, they lose the exploration that makes learning interesting and engaging.

Understanding this I started focusing on the designing of my lessons as the beginning of the exploration process. Lesson design is key to student engagement. Is this lesson just delivering information? If so, why does it need a teacher to do it? Why not show students a YouTube video? Why not have an AI explain the topic? Information delivery is increasingly something technology can accomplish anyway. Or is this lesson creating an experience that makes students want to learn? I began learning to create lessons where students actually wanted to participate and even asked me to repeat. One example that stands out in my mind involved teaching students about the First World War. Rather than simply asking students to recall information about the war, I designed an assignment where they had to write a letter home from the battlefield. They needed to incorporate the historical information we had discussed in class, trenches, rats, gunfire, no-man’s land, etc. and they had to describe why it was so painful to live through. I was amazed at some of the creativity that some students displayed, and they all learned the challenging material well. The students weren’t simply listing facts about trench warfare or describing historical events, they were considering what those experiences meant for them.

Going forward

Of course not every lesson can be a performance, a game, or an elaborate creative project, but I am suggesting that the lesson designing process is critical to creating student engagement. Sure, some classes can be direct instruction, practice, or structured learning; however I am suggesting that teachers should think about why students would want to participate in those experiences. Education is constantly changing and these days it can be harder than ever to build engaging classrooms because technology has become so ubiquitous and distracting. As I explore the MALAT program I want to increasingly explore the relationship between technology, creativity, and student engagement so I can still create engaging classrooms that get students talking and having fun.

Leave a Comment

Rethinking Education in the Age of AI: Beyond Career Preparation

By Vince Ruffolo
Masters of Arts in Education and Technology, Royal Roads University
LRNT523 – Foundations of Learning and Technologies
Instructor: Elizabeth Childs
October 28th, 2026

Figure 1. Education in 2035: Two possible futures. The contrast illustrates how unequal access to effective AI-supported education could deepen educational inequality, separating engagement in technology-dependent classrooms.
OpenAI. (2026). Two classrooms in 2035: [AI-generated image]. ChatGPT.

By the year 2035, it is possible that artificial intelligence (AI) may have profoundly transformed not only the economy but our education systems as well. In order to identify how students will experience this profound change, we will consider two high school English classes. One is using an educational AI to help students explore literature, develop ideas and assess their learning in ways other than traditional assignments. The other is a classroom of students who are disengaged from a curriculum that seems no longer relevant to them. These two classrooms are both shaped by the proliferation of AI and will raise important questions about the purpose of education in the 21st century. This is because while AI itself is not a problem for education, the ways in which it can be used to achieve educational goals highlight the major flaw in current approaches to education, in that education tends to focus on learning that prepares students for employment (OECD, 2025). If schools value learning for its economic utility more than for its intrinsic value to individual development, then how will education flourish in a post-AI world where human skills are less in demand? As many of the routine tasks that have in the past provided economic value to society are being taken over by AI, schools must ensure that independent thinking, critical judgment, creativity and personal development are valued for their contribution to human development as well as for their economic usefulness (Gmyrek et al., 2025).

The bell rings in my high school English classroom. It is 9 a.m. in 2035 at the private school I work at, and students are filling up the room. There is a sense of enthusiasm as the students continue their personalized learning programs which they have developed together around the Edgar Allan Poe unit we have begun working on. The students open their computers and use the AI educational assistant which helps them to interpret literary texts, challenge conventional thinking, and develop their critical thinking skills. Traditional marks have now disappeared because written assignments are no longer the primary means of demonstrating student learning.  Written work is still valuable as a way to develop students’ ideas, but now teachers assess the thinking of students in different ways to make sure they have actually learned something because AI can generate essays, summarize texts, and construct arguments, so a completed written assignment is not sufficient evidence of student learning. Instead, in the 2035 classroom my students use their personal AI assistants to explore concepts, reason through problems, and evaluate interpretations. They track their own progress and design digital posters to demonstrate their learning via extensive presentations where they explain their ideas and processes. Meanwhile, just down the road, in a public school classroom, there is a different feel. There the room is only half full and the remaining students are no longer interested in the school’s curriculum. Most spend time on their personal devices and ignore the teacher lecturing about the day’s subject. The school is chronically underfunded and the students there have limited opportunities to use the new, powerful educational AI tools.

While these two classrooms seem quite different, they both have something in common, in that they have been radically shaped by the proliferation of AI in society. It is likely that by 2035 the use of AI will have been expanded in education to support many aspects of learning. In literature, for example, AI might enable students to explore in-depth ideas behind the author’s work, it could help them to question the assumptions on which they base their views or help them to challenge conventional ideas. Rather than students having to complete the same assignments or work at the same pace as other students, they could use an AI educational assistant to build personal learning programs which provide instant feedback. Classroom learning could be tailored to students individual interests and needs, however in order to achieve these benefits of AI, students will need to learn how to effectively interact with it. Walter (2024) understood this as he emphasized the need for students to be educated in AI literacy, prompt engineering, and critical thinking so that they can effectively interact with AI, as opposed to just accepting the output from it. Lee and Low (2024) similarly argue that generative AI should be integrated into education in ways that promote critical thinking. These arguments support the possibility that AI could help students explore literature, question assumptions, and develop their own interpretations.

However, while AI could potentially be an excellent learning tool, I would also argue that providing students with AI tools does not necessarily mean that they will automatically benefit from them. When learning with the aid of AI, there is no guarantee that students will achieve meaningful learning because there is a risk that students could become dependent on AI to interpret texts, develop critical thinking, and accept the answers that it provides without further thought or investigation. Moreover, the way that AI is introduced, who has access to it, and what educational goals it is used to achieve will determine if it will support meaningful learning or further exacerbate existing inequalities in education. These aspects of AI in education were explored by Macgilchrist et al. (2020) and Selwyn et al. (2020), as their work suggests that the effects of AI will depend not only on technological developments, but also on the decisions schools and policymakers make about how it is used and what education should achieve. They explore alternative futures for education and technology, emphasizing the choices involved in shaping them. Macgilchrist et al. (2020) write that “each future history means decisions have been taken about which technologies, institutions, funding lines, research, pedagogies, relations, designs, etc, to prioritise” (p. 87). Aboodi (2025) also examines the risk of outsourcing critical thinking to AI, highlighting the possibility that people may rely on AI to do their thinking rather than developing their own judgment. He explains that “outsourcing critical thinking to AI could be as simple as asking an AI chatbot a question that calls for critical thinking and relying on the answer without considering the matter on one’s own” (p. 629). This point is important because students can complete an assignment using AI without necessarily understanding the context of the material or having developed the skills that the assignment is intended to teach (Aboodi, 2025; Fischer et al., 2024). For example, a student studying an Edgar Allan Poe story might accept an AI-generated interpretation without evaluating its evidence or considering alternative explanations causing the student to produce work that is not meaningful evidence of their learning.

In addition to the question of how AI can best support meaningful learning, the widespread use of AI also brings up a larger issue with regards to the purpose of education; this is one area where our current career-focused education model is lacking. A major concern about the classroom of 2035 is: what will happen to the relationship between education and work when AI starts to change that relationship? When education is viewed, in part, as an asset that pays off in terms of job prospects, as we see today, a post-AI world could see fewer people valuing spending years in a classroom. To highlight this problem, I introduced in my 2035 scenario a guaranteed basic income (GBI) provided to assist citizens who are dealing with the possible widespread unemployment potentially resulting from the use of AI in the economy. This thought experiment helps to illustrate the potential impact a decoupling of education and employment could have on public funding of schools. Selwyn et al. (2020) also explored similar speculative scenarios to examine how digital technologies could reshape schools and the people within them. Their work supports my approach of using a 2035 scenario to explore how changes in technology and the economy might challenge existing assumptions about the purpose of education.

It is important to note that the technology itself does not determine which outcome occurs; rather, that the outcome depends on how schools and policymakers choose to implement and fund the technology. Therefore, such a decoupling and subsequent lack of funding could potentially mean that the benefits of AI in education are unlikely to benefit all students equally. Instead, there could be a significant risk of a two-tier educational system where public schools in particular may become chronically underfunded. This concept is supported by Singh and Maughan (2014) who examined the benefits and limitations of educational technology according to people’s economic and social circumstances. Their imagined scenarios illustrated how some learners could gain access to expensive educational opportunities and advanced technologies, while others potentially faced significant constraints allowing better-resourced schools to provide more personalized learning, while underfunded schools struggled to offer students the same opportunities.

AI is here and changing our world. By 2035, underfunding in public schools could contribute to a cycle of declining educational quality and student disengagement, further weakening public confidence in the value of education. However, such an outcome is not inevitable. It is important that education evolves to meet the needs of this change, or it will risk becoming increasingly irrelevant or reproduce even greater student inequalities than already exist. Instead of trying to make AI work within education’s current framework or to spending resources on better detecting its use, schools should instead rethink the purpose of education and shift the focus to assessing students’ ability to think independently, use critical thinking skills, and develop personally (Aboodi, 2025; Lee & Low, 2024; Roberts, 2023). This shift must take place so that all students can experience the benefits of AI and not just those in the wealthiest of schools.

References

Aboodi, R. (2025). The worrisome potential of outsourcing critical thinking to artificial intelligence. Educational Theory, 75(4), 626–645. https://doi.org/10.1111/edth.70037

Fischer, I., Sweeney, S., Lucas, M., & Gupta, N. (2024). Making sense of generative AI for assessments: Contrasting student claims and assessor evaluations. The International Journal of Management Education, 22(3), Article 101081. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijme.2024.101081

Gmyrek, P., Berg, J., Kamiński, K., Konopczyński, F., Ładna, A., Nafradi, B., Rosłaniec, K., & Troszyński, M. (2025). Generative AI and jobs: A 2025 update. International Labour Organization. https://doi.org/10.54394/QFBQ1907

Lee, C. C., & Low, M. Y. H. (2024). Using genAI in education: The case for critical thinking. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, 7, Article 1452131. https://doi.org/10.3389/frai.2024.1452131

Macgilchrist, F., Allert, H., & Bruch, A. (2020). Students and society in the 2020s: Three future ‘histories’ of education and technology. Learning, Media and Technology, 45(1), 76–89. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439884.2019.1656235

OECD. (2025). Education for human flourishing: A conceptual framework. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/73d7cb96-en

Roberts, J. S. (2023, July 14). Decolonizing AI ethics: Indigenous AI reflections. Accel.AI.

Selwyn, N., Pangrazio, L., Nemorin, S., & Perrotta, C. (2020). What might the school of 2030 be like? An exercise in social science fiction. Learning, Media and Technology, 45(1), 90–106. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439884.2020.1694944

Singh, S. S., & Maughan, T. (2014, June 22). The future of ed tech is here, it’s just not evenly distributed. Futures Exchange.

Walter, Y. (2024). Embracing the future of artificial intelligence in the classroom: The relevance of AI literacy, prompt engineering, and critical thinking in modern education. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 21, Article 15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-024-00448-3

AI Use Statement

AI Use Before Assignment 3

For this assignment, I will use AI to help in structuring my thoughts and critically analyze the readings. The AI I commonly use is ChatGPT and it can be useful in investigating the implications of the scenarios I create because it can help to stress test my ideas. I will use AI to help explain complex arguments in the readings and to see how sources I am using relate to one another. AI is useful in locating applicable sources and completing grammar checks. I will ensure that any sources suggested by the AI are checked and I will verify that the publications exist, that the authorship and publication details have been confirmed. I will read the original publications before citing them. I will also make comparisons between AI generated summaries and the actual readings, as I will be careful not to take the AI outputs for granted. I will not use AI to brainstorm my central ideas as I already have a good idea about the direction that I want to build this paper in. My arguments and conclusions will be my own.

AI Use After Assignment 3

AI was useful during my work on this paper as it helped me to develop and refine my ideas and arguments. I found that during the exploration of the readings I would communicate my ideas with the AI and explore the relationship between the artificial intelligence’s interpretations of the readings and my own. This was useful because the AI helped me to locate the weak points in my reasoning and build on my existing ideas, which was very helpful as it caused me to engage further with the ideas proposed by the authors. AI was also helpful in linking my thought experiment arguments and ideas with the academic literature. This helped to refine and better clarify the supporting arguments with my thesis. In addition I used ChatGPT to find awkward phrasing, grammatical errors, and ways to make my writing clearer and more concise. As I reflect on my use of AI after completing my paper, it became clear to me that the paper topic I chose was perhaps rather large for the proposed assignment. I was interested in exploring the ideas and relationship between economic viability and education, which sometimes felt too broad in scope. However AI did help me to manage the points and make the paper more manageable by helping me to focus on the specifics of the ideas I was exploring.

Leave a Comment

The AI dilemma facing education

Image generated using OpenAI’s ChatGPT (2026)

Is the point to educate people to help them navigate their lives and develop personal growth or are we really just going to double down on training students to understand increasingly complex commercial systems so they can work jobs that AI might take anyway? I think that ideas about future classrooms may have underestimated the impact new AI technology is really going to have. As a high school teacher, I have already seen AI create a huge challenge for teachers wanting to continue a traditional educational experience. In the readings, Selwyn et al. (2020) wrote that future technology could increasingly control educational experiences and decisions, but really it seems that generative AI introduces a much deeper change and problem. AI may actually change why we choose to educate students, and for what reasons we do. AI can answer any questions and will increasingly be asked to do many tasks in the workplace. Moreover, it seems that AI not only can accurately produce student work, which has traditionally been a benchmark to evaluate student learning, but it can also think for students as well. I feel somewhat pessimistic about the future of education because I think it is going through an identity crisis. I think we are looking at the commercialization of education because these new technologies are not designed with education in mind, but packaged to schools as educational systems. (Selwyn et al., 2020) One thing is for sure, AI is exposing a flaw in the education to job market model that needed to be addressed years ago.

References

Selwyn, N., Pangrazio, L., Nemorin, S., & Perrotta, C. (2020). What might the school of 2030 be like? An exercise in social science fiction. Learning, Media and Technology, 45(1), 90–106. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439884.2020.1694944

2 Comments

Virtual Reality Learning: Introducing Mel Slater

Virtual Reality Learning: Introducing Mel Slater

By Vince Ruffolo

Mel Slater. Source: ICREA.

My interest in virtual reality technology has led me to Mel Slater who is a foundational figure in VR research. VR has the ability to simulate real world experiences and allows its users to explore environments that they would otherwise not have access to. Due to this incredible potential, it seems promising that this type of technology could revolutionize educational experiences. The work Slater has done since the late 1980’s has focused on users interactions and reactions within entirely computer generated worlds. His research helped create realistic simulation models that would allow professionals to accurately practice real skills in a safe space. These models have directly benefited fields such as medicine, healthcare, and emergency response. (Slater & Sanchez-Vives, 2016)

Mel Slater began his career at the University College London and later moved to the University of Barcelona’s Event Lab where he worked publishing several papers. (ICREA, 2016) At the University of Barcelona, Slater’s work focused on the psychological feeling of truly being inside a virtual environment and the experience of feeling that a virtual body is your own. Moreover, his research made important contributions to the study of embodiment, which shows that the human brain can relate to a virtual body much in the same way it does a physical one. (Slater et al., 2009)

I have become increasingly interested in VR and its practicality in being a genuinely valuable educational tool. Having used VR on several occasions, I believe that it has enormous educational potential because of the incredible immersion that it provides. Slater’s research is going to be pivotal in helping to realize this potential because he demonstrates that effective learning in immersive simulations is not only possible, but that these virtual simulations have similar impacts on the human brain as real world experiences, even when people know they are experiencing a virtual reality.

References

Slater, M., Perez-Marcos, D., Ehrsson, H. H., & Sanchez-Vives, M. V. (2009). Inducing illusory ownership of a virtual body. Frontiers in Neuroscience, 3(2), 214–220.

Slater, M. (2009). Place illusion and plausibility can lead to realistic behaviour in immersive virtual environments. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 364(1535), 3549–3557.

Slater, M., & Sanchez-Vives, M. V. (2016). Enhancing our lives with immersive virtual reality. Frontiers in Robotics and AI, 3, Article 74.

ICREA. (2016). Slater, Mel. ICREA Memoir 2016.

Relevant Links

Meet the Brains – Mel Slater: Virtual Environments in Psychology and Cognitive Neuroscience (Institute of Neurosciences UB, YouTube): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSWrtyBVH2A&t=6s

Mel Slater’s publications are listed at http://publicationslist.org/melslater

AI Transparency Statement

AI was used during this assignment to help brainstorm and identify a researcher who is foundational to the understanding of virtual reality. All links, authors and academic sources were investigated independently and verified for accuracy.

Leave a Comment

LRNT 523 Activity 3: Appling Weller’s ideas to teaching.

Activity 3: Appling Weller’s ideas to teaching.

1. Exploring the ideas behind the virtual world Second Life.

While reading Weller’s book, 25 years of Ed Tech, I was especially intrigued at the section discussing the ideas behind the virtual world of Second Life. Weller explored this game because it is a great example of the potential benefits of VR, specifically in the area of open learning. He points out that when the game was released it carried with it a profound promise to revolutionize educational opportunities. This is because it provided people with a space to explore a digital classroom, effectively emulating the experience that students in the real world would have. However, while Second Life provides an entertaining experience, Weller questions the overall value it provided when delivering a lesson; albeit his point seems to be in regards to general education. Weller does go on to say that in specific contexts, such as medicine or engineering, that VR can provide a useful mechanism for simulation; even if that potential has yet to fully be realized.

As a teacher, having explored the use of VR learning, I think that his point about virtual worlds is very interesting and correctly highlights the pros and cons of the technology. In my experience, when I explored the use of VR in a classroom, I found that the initial impact on students was very effective specifically in bring to life the content that we were engaging with. However, when I compared the results of student learning with other cohorts, I didn’t notice any significant difference in the learning outcomes when I taught the same units later without the VR addition. So should learning be defined simply by the end results? No, I think learning is a process of discovery. Does this mean that VR shouldn’t have a place in the classroom? Well, in today’s current context I would say while we shouldn’t dismiss VR simply because it hasn’t yet demonstrated superior learning outcomes there are logistical issues that prevent its realistic implication. The technology is just not ready yet, but if I asked all the students I’ve taught: What do you remember most about our classroom? I would be confident that the kids that experienced VR would remember that experience as a meaningful part of their education.

2. Exploring the problem with Social Media.

I found the section where Weller explores social media particularly interesting because it demonstrates just how quickly technology can change from its educational use into something fundamentally different. Weller explores social media, particularly Twitter, reflecting on how the technology was exciting in the beginning because it allowed educators to build effective networks of communication. I can see how this innovation could have been genuinely appealing in gathering collective educational ideas quickly in a large network because the conversations would include many new people. The problem is however that the harms of social media have increasingly become problematic enough to a point where they mostly overshadow any of the intended benefits. Weller does articulate that social media can have pros and cons, but this is where I feel his analysis doesn’t go far enough because the weight of the pros and cons are not equal and within certain contexts, especially for teenagers, social media can be actually harmful, as is evident in classroom settings. There is substantial evidence to demonstrate that social media is a problem for student learning because the attention it demands interferes with the learning process (Pyhältö et al., 2025). Looking from an even larger view, social media has also been a large problem educationally for society because it allows misinformation to permeate almost all layers of online conversations on its platforms (OECD, 2024). I think if Weller was to revise his chapter on social media, he might see just how problematic it has become for educational purposes and be more cautious when evaluating its benefits and harms.

References

Pyhältö, K., Rekola, H., Salovuori, S., Kosola, S., & Anttila, H. (2025). The relationship between academic achievement and off-task social media and smartphone usage: Evidence from a systematic literature review.

OECD. (2024). PISA 2022 results (Volume V): Learning strategies and attitudes for life. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/c2e44201-en

Weller, M. (2020). 25 years of ed tech. Athabasca University Press.

Image made with Gemini

AI Use Statement: AI was used to help locate relevant sources, brainstorm ideas, and organize my thoughts. I also used it to discuss my ideas and improve the grammar of the final reflection. The analysis, writing, and personal experiences presented are my own.

Leave a Comment

LRNT 523 Activity 2: Reflecting on 25 Years of Ed Tech

As I read Weller’s book, 25 Years of Ed Tech, I am reminded of the times in my classroom that a student wanted to use a new technology (typically an app) in order to create some learning fun in class for everyone. They would describe how other teachers would use the tech that they liked and subsequently I would usually try out the technology. (I like exploring new ways to make learning fun.) However, I often wondered what real benefit the technology was providing for students short of playtime or novelty and, in most cases, I could not detect any. Weller seems to touch on this topic as well investigating how new technologies are often touted as a solution to old problems, a way to engage students, or a way to change the face of education. But has learning really improved? Or, has it actually gotten worse? I could see that the students were very interested in the activities however; they did not seem to really retain the overall concepts particularly well. This intriguing concept was explored in Children’s and Adolescents’ Learning with Educational Technology, where the American Psychological Association cautions that high student engagement can be frequently mistaken for authentic learning. It explains how fun educational software and gamified learning apps can excel at keeping students engaged and entertained during the activities but that the learning involved is not well retained after the activity. Moreover the study suggests that the interactive interfaces are not equivalent to deep conceptual understanding. (American Psychological Association, 2026)

The concept of the ‘year zero’ mentality explored in Weller’s book is interesting because it shows how people can become excited about what a new technology can do, even if existing technologies are similar and can provide similar experiences. It can lead schools to buy the latest ‘new’ or ‘innovative’ technology because it is the latest, rather than because it specifically improves learning. I suspect this is not necessarily a feature of technology in education but rather how people view new technologies in general. Regarding this, I think a clear example is the new wave of AI technology in company applications. At first there was an overwhelming air that this new technology would revolutionize the work place, but the reality seems to be playing out rather differently. In fact, many companies are looking to roll back their AI initiatives due to ineffectiveness. (Estrada, 2025)

References:

American Psychological Association. (2026). Children’s and adolescents’ learning with educational technology. https://www.apa.org/pubs/reports/children-adolescent-learning-educational-technolog

Estrada, S. (2025, August 18). MIT report: 95% of generative AI pilots at companies are failing. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2025/08/18/mit-report-95-percent-generative-ai-pilots-at-companies-failing-cfo/

Weller, M. (2020). 25 Years of Ed Tech. Athabasca University Press.

Footnote: ChatGPT was used to help locate relevant academic and news sources and serve as a brainstorming partner while I developed and organized my ideas. The opinions, analysis, and conclusions expressed in this reflection are my own.

Leave a Comment

What makes a good research question?

“If we knew what we were doing, it would not be called research, would it?”

– Albert Einstein

What makes a good research Question?

Conducting research is the backbone of scientific discovery. As Dahlberg and McCaig write in the book, Practical Research and Evaluation, “The mission of research is to provide us with knowledge. Research describes and explains phenomena surrounding us”(Dahlberg & McCaig, 2010). For many aspiring students who want to learn how to conduct proper research reading this book can provide them with sound advice, namely suggesting that for students to best understand how research is conducted it is important for them to understand the fundamentals of research. Upon reading Practical Research and Evaluation it becomes evident that these fundamentals begin with a good research question. Dahlberg and McCaig (2010) discuss the importance of this by saying, “research projects and evaluations start with a question or problem. This may be both broad and vague. To make it possible to illuminate the problem through research, the problem has to become specific and focused, that is, it has to be developed into one or several research questions. Research questions are closely linked to the purpose of the research study. The identification of research questions and the purpose of the study is part of the planning of the study” (Dahlberg & McCaig, 2010). Here the authors provide a clear understanding on the meaning of a good research question and why understanding this process is important. In order to make clear the process of formulating a good research question, the authors provide several well explained points that a potential researcher must follow in order to have their research be of top quality. Of the examples highlighted in the book I have looked closely at two points here in my blog as they seemed very relevant; that is the need for a focused and researchable question.

Focused – This means a research question needs to be specific, narrow and precise. It needs to concentrate on a particular part of a larger topic and avoid being too broad. This allows for an in depth peer reviewable investigation on a topic rather than a generalization leading to a much clearer informational outcome. “Vaguely stated theories and hypotheses serve no purpose… theories that are stated precisely and make specific predictions can be shown more easily to be wrong and are therefore better” (Dahlberg & McCaig, 2010).

Researchable – This means that the research topic should be something that can be answered through systematic investigation and research. It should not look into topics that are considered pseudoscientific because information in these areas cannot be researched or even verified by peer reviewing. Similarly, philosophical questions are inherently opinion-based and do not lend themselves to observable research which is required in the peer reviewing process.

It is evident that the nature of a good research question can be summarized by its specificity and its ability to be effectively researched. The development of a precise and focused research question is essential when beginning to conduct a comprehensive research that would provide peer reviewable results. Moreover, as Dahlberg & McCaig point out, a research question should be researchable, which means that the answer to the question should be achievable through research and based on evidence that can be observed by others (Dahlberg & McCaig, 2010). Thus, by following these principles researchers will be able to meet global scientific standards for quality and bring valuable findings to the scientific community.

Sources

Dahlberg, L., & McCaig, C. (2010). Practical research and evaluation: A start-to-finish guide for practitioners. SAGE Publications Ltd.

Fisher, S. (2021, February 4). 17 Research quotes to inspire and amuse you. Qualtrics. © 2024. Retrieved from https://www.qualtrics.com/blog/research-quotes/

Leave a Comment

Exploring Connections Between Poverty, Global Access and the Digital Divide

by Vince Ruffolo and Mo Kassanga

Impact of Digital Learning on poverty and Digital Divide

How inequality and poverty affect people around the world. Digital learning has significant impact on both poverty and the digital divide, with various positive and negative implications. By Mo K.

Digital learning can be defined simply as: “learning that is supported by Technology.” Walker, Mark. (2024) Poverty is defined as the state or condition in which people or communities cannot meet a minimum standard of living because they lack the proper resources. These include (but are not limited to) financial resources, basic healthcare and education clean drinking water and infrastructure (poverty, n.d.)

Here are the notes associated with the understanding that has taken place on this topic:

  • Some insight is given first on the meaning of the terminologies used in the topic title followed by the bulleted list of impacts with relevant explanations.
  • Digital Learning encompasses a broad range of educational practices that utilizes digital technologies to facilitate learning. It includes various modes of delivery such as:
  • Online Learning – A form of distance education where the primary delivery mechanism is via the internet.
  • Blended Learning – This combines both online and face-to-face teaching.
  • Hybrid Learning – Similar to blended learning, but often involves a more significant redesign of the learning experience. Students do the majority of their learning online, coming to campus only for specific face-to-face activities that cannot be done satisfactorily online.
  • HyFlex Learning – This model gives student the choice of how they participate in the course, whether online or in-person, and allows them to switch between modes as needed.
  • Open learning – This includes open educational resources (OER) like open text books, which are freely accessible and can be downloaded by students and instructors.
  • MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses) – These are fully open courses available online to any one, and often for free.
  • Flexible learning – This approach provides student with more choices regarding when, where and how they learn.

Digital divide is a term that refers to the gap between demographics and regions that have access to modern Information and Communication Technology (ICT), and those that don’t or have restricted access. This technology can include the Telephone, television, personal computers and Internet connectivity. (digital-divide, n.d.)

Positive Impacts can be described as follows:

Increased access to education:

  • Digital learning provides educational opportunities to individuals in remote or underserved areas where traditional educational infrastructure is lacking. This helps in bridging the educational gap between urban and rural areas.
  • A developing country can draw on teachers with superior knowledge from advanced countries rather than local teachers who first have to learn the requisite skills before they can train others. Khan, H. & Williams, J. (2006).

Flexibility and Convenience:

  • Digital learning offers flexibility, allowing students to learn at their own pace and on their own schedule. This can be particularly beneficial for working adults or those with family responsibilities.

Cost-effective education

  • Digital learning reduces the cost associated with traditional education, such as transportation, housing, and physical text books. Open educational resources (OER) and MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses) provides free or low cost learning materials.

Skill Development:

  • Digital learning platforms often offers courses in high demand skills, such as coding, digital marketing and data analysis, which improves employability and potentially lift individuals out of poverty.

Negative  Impacts can be described as follows:

Access Inequality:

  • Not everyone has equal access to the necessary technology and internet connectivity required for digital learning. This is particularly true for low income families and those in rural or remote areas, exacerbating the digital divide.

Quality of Learning:

  • The quality of digital learning can vary significantly. Student from Wealthier backgrounds may have access to better resources, such as high quality devices and faster internet, as well as more support from parents and tutors.

Digital Literacy:

  • Effective participation in digital learning requires a certain level of digital literacy. Those who lack these skills, often from poorer backgrounds, may struggle to benefit fully from online education.

Support systems:

  • Student from low income families may lack the necessary support systems at home, such as quite place to study or parental guidance, which can hinder their ability to succeed in a digital learning environment.

Mitigation Strategies can be exampled as follows:

Government and Institutional Support:

  • Government and educational institutions can provide subsidies or loans for digital devices and internet access for low income families. They can also invest in public Wi-Fi hot spots and community centers with internet access.

Teacher Training:

  • Training teachers to effectively use digital tools and platforms can improve the quality of Online education and ensure that all student receive a high standard of education.

Digital Literacy Programs

  • Implementing digital literacy programs can help equip student and their families with the necessary skills to navigate and benefit from digital learning platforms.

Policy Interventions:

  • Policies aimed at reducing poverty, such as improving economic opportunities and social services, can indirectly improve access to digital learning by addressing the root cause of the digital divide.

In conclusion, while digital learning has the potential to reduce educational inequalities and provide opportunities for those in poverty, it also risks exacerbating existing disparities if not carefully managed. Ensuring equitable access to technology and support systems is crucial for maximizing the benefit of digital learning for all.

Controlled Access: How China’s Internet Policies Shape Learning

How China’s Communist Party policies affect the digital learning landscape in China: Positive and Negative Points about China’s Online Infrastructure. By Vince R.

How China’s Policies Affect Student Learning and Education in China

The Chinese government has made efforts to build a nationwide digital learning system with abundant open resources to promote education equity. This initiative has been met with both positive and negative features when related to the learning quality for Chinese students. It is evident that a more constructive learning outcome is associated with better DLE equipment and network conditions, which positively affects learning performance in students. This also highlights evident negative features which denote that positive learning performance is linked to economic conditions.

Positive: The CPC has emphasized online education in the 19th National Congress report, which demonstrates major development. China has demonstrated that it is focused on building basic infrastructure for online education, which has been referred to as the implementation of the “Modern Distance Education Project.” Development of the National K-12 Education Resource Network.

Positive: When the iPhone was introduced in 2007 it greatly accelerated Internet access across China. It was this adoption of mobile Internet which led to a significant increase in online education; shifting it from a supplementary role to a key pillar of Chinese education.

Positive: The “Double Reduction” policy was brought in to reduce homework and significantly eliminate off-campus training burdens. Also included were measures to standardize and regulate online education.

Positive: China has gone through four stages in the development of online education policies, and the future of online education in China looks promising due to the existing polices and different measures to promote lifelong learning and education for all.

Negative: Despite the rapid development of online education, challenges remain. Some issues within the development of online education are the digital divide, supervision of the teaching process, and cooperation with the enterprise, which needs more comprehensive initiatives for further improvement.

Negative: Some of the concerns which are associated with the topic include “false propaganda” and “price gouging” by some institutions that offer education.

Positive: In the last few years, there is an increase in the use of online education in the rural areas.

The Online Learning Survey conducted by the Big Data Center of the Graduate School of Education, Peking University, showed that China’s policy was indeed supportive of digital education. It determined the following: The findings of the study revealed that family income, parents’ education level, and professional status influenced online learning among students in China.

Positive: During Covid 19 the Chinese Ministry of Education mandated a nationwide shift to online learning to maintain educational continuity during the pandemic.

Negative: 18.4% of students reported inadequate equipment. 37.3% faced network issues. 46.95% of high school students reported a decrease in overall learning scores.

Positive: Governments and schools provided free access to extensive online learning materials and platforms like Zoom and Tencent Classroom.

Negative: However, some challenges were observed during the implementation of the program, including network congestion, poor quality of hardware, and limited interactions between the teachers and students. As a result, students who had access to better resources at home were able to use online resources to their advantage, which could have further amplified the existing disparities in learning outcomes between students from different backgrounds.

Positive: Over 200 million students participated in online classes as part of the official curriculum from February to August 2020.

Negative: There was a significant positive relationship between student success and equipment and internet quality. The students from the low economic class experienced more challenges. These challenges affected the quality and efficiency of online teaching negatively. Furthermore, these problems revealed the existing digital divide in China, which did not disappear during the pandemic and affected the fairness of online learning.

It is evident that China’s Communist Party policies in the field of digital learning are diverse and can be observed in both positive and negative aspects. The government’s long-term commitment to the implementation of a comprehensive digital learning system has greatly enhanced educational equality and student inclusion throughout the country. Measures such as the “Modern Distance Education Project” and the “Double Reduction” policy show a clear willingness to build online education facilities, decrease homework pressure, and regulate online education.

There are positive aspects inherent in China’s digital initiative such as strengths of China’s web infrastructure which include the fast growth of primary infrastructure, the extensive utilization of a mobile web (after the advent of iPhone), and the large-scale application of online education in rural regions. Such advancements have made it possible to have a sound online education system. Moreover this is evident with the government’s preparedness during the COVID 19 outbreak where over 200 million students were taking their classes online and there was a wide range of free online learning resources available.

Nevertheless, these advancements come with significant challenges. The issue of digital divide persists, as the quality of equipment and the access to the internet differ, leading to the creation of different learning environments. Chinese family income and parents’ education level heavily determine the online learning experience of students, thus exacerbating the disparities in the education sector. Other challenges such as network congestion, lack of hardware, and limited face-to-face interaction between teachers and students also contribute to these problems.

Sources

Guo C, Wan B. The digital divide in online learning in China during the COVID-19 pandemic. Technol Soc. 2022 Nov;71:102122. doi: 10.1016/j.techsoc.2022.102122. Epub 2022 Sep 13. PMID: 36118102; PMCID: PMC9468296. 

Jiang, Y., Shang, J., & Jiao, L. (2023). Review of China’s Online Education Policy, 1999–2022. ECNU Review of Education, 6(1), 155-182. https://doi.org/10.1177/20965311221099581

Walker, M.D. What is Digital Learning? In: Digital Learning. How modern technology is Changing education. Sicklebrook publishing, Sheffield U.K.,2024

Khan, Habibullah & Williams, Jeremy. (2006). Poverty Alleviation Through Access to Education: Can E-Learning Deliver?. SSRN Electronic Journal. 10.2139/ssrn.1606102.

Poverty. (n.d.). Investopedia. Retrieved May 25, 2024 from https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/poverty.asp

 Digital-divide. (n.d.) techtarget. Retrieved May 25, 2024 from https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/definition/digital-divide

All art was made using https://www.craiyon.com/

1 Comment

Unit 3 Reading Reflections

During the unit 3 readings it struck me just how much the internet has changed over the years and what implication that has for people navigating today’s digital landscape. When I was about seventeen, I remember going over to my friend’s house to see this new concept on his computer called ‘the internet’. It was text based and while it really opened my mind to what was technologically possible, it was predominantly in the realm of written information and therefore truly lacked any type of user interaction. All these years later the internet has become unrecognizable. It is now so much more than finding information; it is communities, interactions and connections.

The internet has grown and changed in many magnificent ways and also created unintended consequences for humanity. We use the internet for virtually every aspect of our lives and there is growing evidence that this fact increasingly comes at a human cost. A paper called the ‘Psychological Effects of the Internet Use’ mentions on this topic that “the ever-increasing use of computers has a negative impact on the health of users affecting various systems and causing physical and mental problems.” (Diomidous M, 2016) I suspect that the internet in the coming years will be considered in a different light and navigated with far more savvy, careful consideration and mindfulness then may have been needed in years past. I think this idea is reflected in the Participatory Open video (Stewart, Phipps, & Cormier, 2019) where it was evident (even a few years ago) that people have been demonstrating a growing mindset towards online caution and communal awareness.

Sources

Diomidous M, Chardalias K, Magita A, Koutonias P, Panagiotopoulou P, Mantas J. Social and Psychological Effects of the Internet Use. Acta Inform Med. 2016 Feb;24(1):66-8. doi: 10.5455/aim.2016.24.66-68. Epub 2016 Feb 2. PMID: 27041814; PMCID: PMC4789623. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4789623/

Stewart, B., Phipps, L., & Cormier, D. (2019). The Participatory open: Can we build a Pro-Social, Pro-Societal web? [Video]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D4tg1FnE_s

1 Comment

Visualizing my Digital Network

For the unit 3 visual network map task, I have made an interesting illustration of my online activities and the corresponding interlocking connections. In order to facilitate this assignment I have used the website called Kumu, which I have not used before this point although I found to be rather easy to learn. There were several features that became evident in this assignment, namely the fact that many of the online applications that I use are very much interconnected providing numerous diverse interactions among my professional and personal life.

I know that I spend a fair amount of my time online and this illustration is a testament to this fact, however upon review it is clear that the majority of this activity time is spent mostly with personal communications and interactions with family and friends. One of the significant reasons that I am interacting so frequently online in this manner is due to challenges posed by large geographical distances. As I have been working overseas for some time, I have had a diminished ability to stay connected with friends and family other than utilizing online platforms. Moreover many of my friends have also moved away to other distant locations for various reasons and online interactions have become a consistent way to keep connected. As reflected in my diagram, I use a few different methods of connecting online to propagate my social interactions, however I tend to use the media platform Steam the most frequently.

While staying connected in my personal life online is important, many of the various online platforms I use are for work or school reasons.

In the MALAT program there are numerous online platforms and activities that have been brought to my attention, some of which I have never used before and am unsure I will again after the program. I can tell that I gravitate to a few network hubs and avoid having large network connections that will remain mostly un utilized.

In the case of work I use minimal digital social networking connections. I tend to prefer having work interactions being in person (when possible) and thus focus more on information gathering websites when online. There are several reasons why I limit online social networks within my work sphere, although the main reason I would say is that I am a proponent of the idea of ‘unplugging’ after a work period. I find the more minimal my work related social network activity is, the easier it is to accomplish disconnecting from my work environment.

1 Comment